St. Joseph Agency traces its roots to 1977 when it was founded as Life Insurance Brokerage Agency Inc. selling life, health and disability insurance.
Changes came in 2009 when our name, St. Joseph Agency, was selected for the qualities of St. Joseph as provider and protector of the Holy Family. The agency expanded to include property and casualty carriers offering auto, homeowners and commercial insurance. The following year the agency purchased and remodeled the property at 601 E. 106th St. in southern Hamilton County.
Our goal is to provide our clients protection with top-rated carriers at a reasonable price with outstanding service and integrity.
Gordon served as an Executive Vice President of Key Life Insurance Company and brings the strength of more than 25 years of insurance sales and marketing background to the position. Smith is licensed in Life, Accident, & Health, as well as Property & Casualty insurance. He has an extensive background in individual products and specialty products. He is President and Owner of St. Joseph Agency. Gordon earned the Eagle Scout distinction in 1972 as a member of Troop 73.
Smith is a current board member of Catholic Radio Indy 89.1 FM and a former board member of Right to Life of Indianapolis, where he served as treasurer and was recipient of the Charles E. Stimming Pro-Life Award. He has served on several other corporate and not-for-profit boards as well. A parishioner of St. Maria Goretti, he serves on various committees and youth programs, as well as being a member of the music ministry choir and brass quartet. Gordon and his wife Mary Ann have eight children.
B.S. from Indiana University
317-564-4949 opt. 5
gsmith@stjosephagency.com
Eric has a background in government relations in both the public and private sector. He joined the agency in 2009 and currently manages the agency’s property and casualty operations. He brings management, sales and business development experience. Smith sits as Owner and Vice President.
Eric attends St. Maria Goretti parish and resides in Westfield with his wife and four children. He enjoys basketball, walking the Monon Trail and enjoys the local restaurant scene. Smith is an Eagle Scout and an active father and husband.
B.A. from the University of Dayton
M.B.A. from Indiana Wesleyan University
317-564-4949 opt. 3
esmith@stjosephagency.com
Twyla began her career in the non-profit world before serving for four years as Community Relations Coordinator at St. Clare Medical Center (now Franciscan St. Elizabeth Health--Crawfordsville). Her education and previous work experience is in Public Relations, Mareting and Journalism. She recently re-entered the (part-time) workforce after several years of enjoying the vocation of motherhood.
Twyla has volunteered for Shepherd’s Gate Food Pantry at St. Maria Goretti Catholic Church since 2001. She is the mother of three children and an active volunteer at St. Maria Goretti Catholic School where she serves as editor of the yearbook and library volunteer. In addition, she manages the Facebook page of the Hopkins Family Park in Gibson County, Indiana.
B.A. from Indiana State University
317-564-4949 opt. 4
tarnold@stjosephagency.com
Peter has a background in customer service in various roles. He joined the agency in 2018 and assists in the account management of existing property and casualty customers.
Peter is a graduate of Guerin Catholic High School. He is a talented guitar enthusiast, avid painter and enjoys running and spending time with family.
Ball State University
